28th August 2008

The story and the context

posted in OmegaDotter, Parenting, Racism, School |

I was sitting at the computer tearing my hair out, trying to figure out just why a test web form wasn’t posting.  (I still haven’t figured it out.)  The phone rings.  I let it ring once, so I can see who is calling.  Plumber?  OmegaDad?  Someone else?

Someone else:  T. Biggle, sayeth the little LED screen.

T. Biggle just happens to be the principal of OmegaDotter’s school.

Instantly, the worrier in me rose up full force.  OMG, the dotter’s been sent to the principal’s office!  OMG, the dotter is hurt and they’re letting us know!  OMG, it’s yet another recorded message about school spirit!  We have been getting message after message from Mr. Biggle related to school; there’s a before-school barbeque, remember to register this week, first day of school is tomorrow and we’re all excited to see you again, join the PTA, blah, blah, blah.  I mean, yeah, it’s nice that they communicate, but maybe they could communicate just a leetle less?  Or do two–two–two messages for the price of one?

Anyway, there it was:  T. Biggle on the phone.

I punch the button.

“Hello?  Is Mrs. OmegaMom available?”

“This is she…”  OMG, it’s not a message, what’s wrong?!

“Nothing is wrong with OmegaDotter–”  Obviously, he’s used to parents panicking when they get the phone call from the principal. “–and she’s done nothing wrong.”  Obviously, he’s used to parents thinking their kids have gotten into trouble when they get the phone call from the principal.

“But there was an incident that we thought you should know about.”

So, out of the blue (apparently), while the dotter and this other kid were putting things away, he tells her, “I don’t like little Chinese girls!”

I don’t think I’ve ever felt quite as much like someone kicked me in the guts as I did when I heard Mr. Biggle tell the story.  He said that OmegaDotter was very upset, her feelings were hurt, she was crying, and that he thought I should hear about it so that we could give her some extra lovin’s when she got home.  He assured me that The Perpetrator was reprimanded, and that the school takes things like this seriously.  (Well, hellyeah, when they actually call me about it, I’d say that was “taking it seriously”, which actually makes me feel pretty damned good about the school.)

So, still feeling like someone had kicked me in the guts, I posted.

And I called OmegaDad, who promptly wanted to boil someone (The Perpetrator) in oil.

And we both agreed that I should do a little something with the dotter when she got home.

And we both worried that she wouldn’t say anything about it, and how the hell do you open up a conversation like that, and what do you say?

So I waited at the bus stop, wondering if she’d be a limp, noodly crying child, or would need a hug, or just ignore things.  The bus arrived, she got off, she barreled into me with a hug, we walked off down our street holding hands.  I’m racking my brain for a good way to start the conversation, and she says:

“Mr. Biggle is going to call you.”

Well!  Whaddaya know!  I didn’t have to start things off at all!  And she wasn’t a puddle of tears, just matter-of-fact.  So I allowed as how he had already called, and did she want to talk about things.

“No.”  She darted off to grab a brilliant red leaf from a shrub, then said, “Oh!  I need to give you a note about the bad thing I did in music today.”  “Bad Thing”?  What’s this?!  I haven’t heard about this! I think to myself.  She stops dead in the middle of the street, pulls her backpack off, requests that I hold it, and starts rummaging around in it.

Oy!  One thing after another!

She hands me a “Thinking Page” which shows a drawing of a little girl bouncing about, a written “I wuz takking”, and a drawing of what she was supposed to be doing (sitting still and listening).

I’m supposed to sign this thing and return it.  In the meantime…

Of course, the plumber appears right then, so while she was rummaging about the garbage disposal, the dotter did homework, and finally the plumber leaves (no fixed disposal, but a new one coming tomorrow a.m.) and I say, “Let’s go get ice cream.”

So we went to C0ld St0ne Creamery, had ice cream, and she told me the story pretty straightforwardly.

Seems that she and Jay were working with their pattern blocks (?  don’t ask me.) and they started arguing about something.  And arguing.  And finally Jay said–fed up–”I’m going to tell everyone that Chinese girls are mean!  I don’t like little Chinese girls!”

So:  The Perpetrator is a six-year-old boy who has been in class with OmegaDotter for a year, who said this in the heat of an argument.

My stomach feels a lot better.  It wasn’t out of the blue, it wasn’t something learned at home, it was something in the heat of the moment.  Still not nice, but hellalot better than I thought.  However, we have re-iterated to the dotter that (a) she should be proud to be Chinese and American; (b) if anyone says something like that to her, here are some things she can say; (c) it was a mean thing to say; and (d) if anyone says anything like that to her again, she should tell us.

(My contribution was she should say, out loud, “I’m proud to be Chinese.  It’s better to be born Chinese than to be born mean.”  OmegaDad’s contribution was she should say, out loud, “I’m sorry you feel that way.  You’ll miss out on getting to know lots of cool and interesting people–like me–if you feel like that.”  For what it’s worth.)

There are currently 13 responses to “The story and the context”

  1. 1 On August 28th, 2008, Sister Carrie said:

    Oh! My heart was in my throat for a while there. Both your comebacks are great.

  2. 2 On August 28th, 2008, k2 said:

    Oh, no.

    Your comebacks are nicer than mine would have been, I’m ashamed to admit. How about ‘And I don’t like jerks’?

  3. 3 On August 28th, 2008, you know where you are with said:

    Somebody did a study a number of years ago now on road rage, and discovered that the first comeback, the first reaction, of nearly *everyone* was to utter a racial epithet. Even though it was about someone else’s bad driving, it was characterized in terms of their race.

    So, when you say that this statement *wasn’t* “learned at home,” I’m not so sure.

  4. 4 On August 29th, 2008, Blog Antagonist said:

    Oooh. Both very good answers. But truthfully, I like yours a smidge better.

  5. 5 On August 29th, 2008, carosgram said:

    Sounds like it was well handled by all! Way to go!

  6. 6 On August 29th, 2008, Vanessa said:

    Excellent job! You all handled the situation with aplomb.

  7. 7 On August 29th, 2008, Johnny said:

    I’m glad the principal was on top of it and let you know. Many times, because of legal concerns, they are mum about things like that.

  8. 8 On August 29th, 2008, noreen said:

    Now I can breath, but I think what you and OmegaDad suggested was much more articulate than I could have come up with.

  9. 9 On August 30th, 2008, lizard said:

    I’ve been working on comebacks for meanness– not this one in particular, but the more general nastiness that my kid got recently (”you hula hoop like a monkey” among others from one particularly nasty little girl).

    I also resorted to “I will learn to hula hoop better, but you will always be mean.”

    Sigh. It is hard loving your kid so much and watching them get hurt in the way all kids get hurt. Ugh.

  10. 10 On August 30th, 2008, preTzel said:

    You were nicer in your comeback then I was. I think that speaks volumes. ;)

    I’ve always told the boys to say things like “Bullies never get anywhere in life except for prison.” Or they could say “Yeah, well my mom kicked your mom’s ass at the spa.” They all agree that the second choice isn’t allowed at school.

    Of course Teen once called someone a “motherfucker” after the kid sliced him in the ribs with a pair of wire cutters. I defended my son’s actions by saying “He said it nicer than I would have.” Yep, stellar parenting moment. :)

  11. 11 On August 31st, 2008, DS-L said:

    You handled the situation well, I would add only that I give my kids the context too. “That was racist. He was saying mean things about you because of your race and that’s racist.” Some don’t think 6 year olds can be racist, but I am worried more about my kids being able to properly identify what the world and the people in it will throw at them. (For record two boys, 11, and 7 hapa Chinese-American, one daughter 4 from China)

    On another note, I am looking for an in depth insightful post on Sarah Palin. I am looking to you, OmegaMom!
    DS-L

  12. 12 On September 8th, 2008, Val said:

    It’s kewl that she told they truth… and the whole story. I like her.

  13. 13 On September 8th, 2008, Val said:

    THE truth.

    I wish there was an edit feature.

Leave a Reply