28th November 2007

Birthmother. Birthmother, birthmother, birthmother.

posted in Adoption, Family, Issues, OmegaDotter, Parenting |

There.  Is it so damned hard to say?!

No.

It’s not.

Jen, over at MimiBoo, mentions, towards the end of her post on anxious attachment, a discussion on a list she’s on about “what do you call your child’s birthmother?”  Much to my dismay (and Jen’s), the “tummy lady” term is still being used, as in “you grew in her tummy, so she’s your tummy lady”.

Oy!

(Aside from the objectification of the birthmother that the phrase embodies, I can’t stand the concept of teaching that pregnancy means “coming from someone’s tummy”.  It’s my own hang-up, and poor OmegaDotter will probably complain to her therapist when she’s 30 that her mother kept telling her how babies grow in uteruses whenever she tried the “I grew in her tummy” statement.)

In this house, we call our child’s birthmother ”your mommy in China”.  Or “your Chinese mommy”.  Or, “your birthmother”.  And it’s “your daddy in China”, and “your other grandparents, who you have never met”.

I made damned sure those words would come easy to me by the time the dotter really needed to talk about such concepts.  I practiced telling her them from the day we brought her home.  Maybe the first time or two it was difficult.  But as a result, these days we have a dotter who feels quite safe in asking questions about her birthmother while we’re eating dinner, and let me tell you, that’s mighty damned important to me.

A helluva lot more important than reserving the Sacred Word “mommy” or “mother” for my use alone.

The “Tummy lady” term has repulsed me since the day I heard that Rosie O’Donnell was using that as her term for birthmother to her adopted children.  It wasn’t because it was being used by Rosie (har!), it was because it seemed to be–and still does seem to be–a way of deliberately distancing yourself and your child from her family of birth, a way of giving lipservice to the idea of discussing birthfamily without having to actually deal with the emotional reality.  OmegaDad, when I discussed it with him in bed last night, wrinkled his nose at the phrase and called it “incredibly impersonal”.

Of course, I have to hold my scorn towards people who use that term in check right now–because I have no idea what I’ll be like if OmegaDotter actually finds her birthmother.  Here and now, the main reaction I have to terms like “tummy lady” is:  Being comfortable with the term, the idea, of “birthmother” is not about me.  It’s about my dotter.  It’s not my life that was yanked about without my consent–it’s hers.  And if feeling comfortable enough to talk about her birth family while her mouth is full of cheesy pasta helps her, then that’s what counts.

There are currently 16 responses to “Birthmother. Birthmother, birthmother, birthmother.”

  1. 1 On November 28th, 2007, Julie Pippert said:

    It is dehumanizing. I hadn’t heard that term. Tummy lady. Wow. I’m pretty sure that wouldn’t occur to me, but then I prefer correct terms.

    Birthmother.

    Yep, pretty easy.

    Julie
    Using My Words

  2. 2 On November 28th, 2007, lisa said:

    Seems amazing that I never heard that term before Jen mentioned it, in the 11 years I have been involved in the adoption community-it must be one of those things I have tuned out. I don’t think any of my friends use it, but then it’s a family discussion, so I may have missed it. I remember knowing what a uterus is back in 1st grade-we weren’t raised with euphemisms. But maybe it is harder to recognize for families that are used to creating distance on complicated subjects? Sigh.
    I have had several discussions with my extended family about HSH’s birthfamily, and they have followed my lead naturally on language, but I worry about the influence of other adoptive families in our lives. ~lmc

  3. 3 On November 28th, 2007, kris said:

    i used to say ‘the woman who gave birth to you’…what an ass i was! i got over myself pretty quick and now use birth mother (or mom) or i have actually just said ‘your mom’ and followed it up with, you know, your birth mom…in vietnam.. it’s just hard for some people to get the words out the first time but they do need to do it and get over themselves. and frankly tummy lady is just , well, stupid.

  4. 4 On November 28th, 2007, carosgram said:

    Good post on a sensitive subject!

  5. 5 On November 28th, 2007, figlet said:

    Yeah, it’s seriously awful. Awful. Gawd.

  6. 6 On November 29th, 2007, Lauri said:

    Great Post…. we use the term Birth Mother or Russian Mommy… although Livi does not ” get” it yet at age three, I agree that it has to be something that I get comfy with really fast.

    I don’t mind sharing the Mama title one bit

  7. 7 On November 29th, 2007, Sparky said:

    There are plenty of people who object to the term birth mother for the very same reasons. In our house we use lots of different terms…first mom natural mom, birth mom, bio mom,, mom in China etc, etc (not that Grace really understands this yet as she’s only 18 months old). It is a complex thing this adoption stuff and I don’t think there is one right way for everyone.

  8. 8 On November 29th, 2007, Blog Antagonist said:

    I’m not an adoptive parent, as you know, and I’m not big on euphemisms in general. However, that one strikes me as particularly icky, as it seems to really diminish the role that a very real human being has played in bringing a child into the world.

    Good on ya for calling a spade a spade.

  9. 9 On November 29th, 2007, Spacemom said:

    The phrase in our house is “Food goes in your tummy, not babies. Babies grow in your womb or uterus” (Soleil is hooked on womb…she thinks it’s a cool word!)

    Tummy mommy? Pul-ease

  10. 10 On November 29th, 2007, mary said:

    Great post — I completely agree. My kids each have 2 moms — it is fact. It also is vital that I am comfortable with that fact so I also started practicing when they were babies. I also practiced my reaction for the “you’re not my real mom” and when it happened it didn’t phase me a bit. This is about our kids NOT us, they need us to be ok with their other mothers. My daughter feels comfortable having me hold her while she cries that she misses her mother — if I was defensive she would hold the sorrow inside which would hurt her even more.

  11. 11 On November 29th, 2007, D said:

    Tummylady? WTF? What’s the birthfather? Penisdude? (oops, hope I didn’t ruin the G rating of your blog…)

    Birthmom and birthfather. It’s simple. Somehow it’s harder for me in German (Geburtsmutter sounds awkward), but I’ll stick with it, anyway.

  12. 12 On November 29th, 2007, Christine said:

    Couldn’t agree more.

  13. 13 On November 29th, 2007, Jean said:

    Hooray for you. That’s the way to go. Five gold stars for you, (snerk).

  14. 14 On November 29th, 2007, Margaret said:

    We haven’t quite reached this point yet (Pippi is only two and a half), but we have done a lot of talking about where DD was born. She knows she and her brother were born in China and that the rest of her (a)family wasn’t. Soon, she’ll ask more about HOW she was born and I think that will be the time I explain about her birth/first family.

    I am worried about her reaction though. I don’t give a crap about the whole “sharing her with another mother” thing. That never troubled me. What I worry about is that she’ll ask me where they are and if we can go see them. I’ll have to explain that we really can’t just go do that. I’m not sure how that whole conversation will go. Ultimately both of my children will come to the understanding that their parents may never be locatable. It’s devastating.

  15. 15 On December 1st, 2007, Miss Cellania said:

    Talking about a birthmother is easy. Hearing your kid refer to her as “my real mother” is hard. I didn’t lose it, but I felt like dying a little inside. After hearing that a few times, I called her on it. (She’s ten years old.) I think she now understands that, although her views on this subject are priority, there are other people involved.

  16. 16 On December 1st, 2007, Kate said:

    Hi, O;

    Catching up on your entries, in case you’re wondering why the multiple comments….

    I was unconscious when I had my baby. For all I know she’s not mine. :)

    She doesn’t look like me.
    Doesn’t like the things I like.
    Switched at birth?

    Perhaps. Doesn’t matter, now. We have bonded and that is what keeps us all strong through life.

    Please! Lose that term of birth Mother right now. Anyone can have a baby. Raising a happy one? Well, that’s another matter. You’re a good Mom. ‘Nuff said.

    And, bein’ a Mom is hard work.

    = kate

Leave a Reply